As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
You can read my full disclosure statement here.
Today we will be talking all about how to plant tomato seeds including which varieties to grow!
Tomatoes are my favorite! I miss them so in the winter months. I want at least one of every color and shape and size! I hope you will have better luck narrowing down the choices. 🙂
Choosing New & Unique Tomato Varieties to Plant
I am adding this video to this post, in September 2019. This is a video that Jessica from Roots & Refuge did with Brad Gates of Wild Boar Farms at the National Heirloom Expo in Santa Rosa, CA the same month.
For those who don’t know who Brad is, he is THE Tomato Man. He has created a lot of the new tomatoes that everyone wants to grow such as Blue Beauty, Black Beauty, Dark Galaxy, Barry’s Crazy Cherry, Atomic Grape, and many many more.
In this video, he talks about how he creates new tomato varieties and how he grows them. I hope after watching this, you too, will grow some new to you varieties!
Choosing Tomatoes For Different Purposes
When you are deciding which tomatoes to grow, think about how you will use them. I like to make a lot of tomato sauce to can up and keep in the pantry. But I don’t like to do it at harvest time, so I freeze them until then. I also love to eat them fresh. And I love to try new varieties as well as stick with the old that have worked well for me or taste the best.
When choosing which ones to grow, I first break down they types of tomatoes to grow, cherry, paste and heirloom. I usually do a few tried and true varieties, and then add some new ones for each category. Breaking them down into these three categories makes it a wee bit less intimidating!
Favorites that I have grow every year:
- Sungold: This is my favorite, and I think that goes for many people. A small orange cherry that is super sweet. Like candy!
- Yellow Pear: This is another favorite that I grow every year, not only for the color (I like lots of different colors, I would never plant all red tomatoes!), but it is also super sweet and it is fun to have a different shape as well.
- Blush: I grew this for the first time last year, and it was a quick favorite. The fruits are oblong in shape, almost like a mini paste tomato and they are a bit larger than most cherries. They are yellow, and as they ripen they get red and orange streaks down them. They have a tougher skin, so they are more resistant to splitting. A very pretty little tomato, perfect for snacking!
This year I am looking forward to these “new to me” cherry varieties:
- Midnight Pear: I’ve always been in love with that cute pear shape, and these are an awesome new color not to be missed! From High Mowing Seeds
- Blue Gold Berry: These are a tiny little productive yellow cherry with black/purple shoulders, so very unique coloring. They also are crack resistant. A Wild Boar tomato seed from Baker Creek Seeds
- Barry’s Crazy Cherry: My friend Paula from Gapey’s Grub raved about these last year and I am so excited to try them this year. They are yellow with a pointed “beak” at the end, and are known to have some of the largest cherry tomato clusters with 40 to 60 fruit per truss! Another Wild Board tomato seed from Baker Creek Seeds
For the past few years, I have grown the same three paste tomato varieties, and I will planting them again this year. But I am excited to try two new varieties this year!
- Striped Roman: This is my absolute favorite. These get HUGE. And they are a pretty red with yellow/orange stripes. Great for fresh eating or for canning. Produces late into the season as well, this was one of the last varieties I was picking along with Orange Peach last fall.
- Amish Paste: These also get huge and are great for canning.
- San Marzano: The classic paste tomato with excellent flavor, great for canning as well.
- Black Icicle: This is the new variety that I am excited to try this year. It has a deep purplish brown color that is almost black, which I am excited to see in a paste tomato. It is rich in taste with earthy undertone and originates from the Ukraine. Available from Baker Creek Seeds
- Purple Russian: This was a freebie in my Baker Creek Seed order, and from what I have read, it sounds very similar to the Black Icicle variety noted above, so it will be fun to compare the two at harvest time.
OK, here is where I have trouble reining things in. Every year I tell myself that I have to plant fewer, but it just doesn’t happen. I currently have 10 old standbys on my list, and really narrowed it down to only 4 new ones to try this year.
I haven’t counted how many I will be growing all in all this year yet, but last year it was 30 varieties….eeek! Hopefully I will keep it to that, but if I have seed still from every variety I grew last year, I guess it will be 34 varieties this year?!?
Past favorites that I have grown before and will grow again this year:
- Ananas Noire (aka: Black Pineapple): This is a very large tomato that is mottled with green, yellow and purple mixed. They can weigh up to 1.5 lbs. The flavor is awesome. High yield. It is one of my very favorites.
- Pineapple: These beauties get up to 1 lb each and are red and yellow streaked. Great flavor also.
- Brandywine and Yellow Brandywine: These are more commonly known favorites, a variety no garden should be without. Large beefsteaks come in at around 1 lb each but not a great producer.
- Cherokee Purple: Another common favorite, brownish purple skin with green shoulders. A nice sized flatter beefsteak at 12-16 oz each, not a heavy producer.
- Black Krim: And yet another common favorite, dark red purplish fruit, originates from Russia. Great sweet flavor, a favorite with chefs.
- Mortage Lifter: Large 1 lb fruits are pink are sweet and such a pretty color!
- Tangerine: These are one of my favorite medium size orange fruits. Creamy texture and sweet.
- Kellogg’s Breakfast: I grew this variety for the first time last year and was very happy with them. Very large fruits that can get as large as 2 lbs! And they are a very pretty peachy orange color.
- Orange Peach: Another new one for me last year. At first I was disappointed in the size as the fruit are rather small, between golf ball and tennis ball size. But they ended up being one of my longest lasting producers, along with the Striped Roman. So for that reason, I will keep them!
- Wild Boar Farms Black Beauty: I grew this for the first time last year also. A novelty tomato and the darkest tomato out there! Great flavor and it stores well.
New varieties for me this year that are all from Baker Creek except for the last one:
- Wild Boar Farms Blue Beauty: I chose this one for the color. It grows up to 8 oz and is sunburn and crack resistant.
- Raspberry Lyanna: This is a raspberry pink fruit that is of medium size that is sweet and richly flavored with firm flesh.
- Mushroom Basket: Ribbed and pleated fruit from Russia, uniform in size and large. Firm flesh with a sweet mild flavor and few seeds.
- Frosty Pink Plum: This one will be a bit of a mystery as I got it from someone who received seeds from someone who had handed them down for a few generations, so I’m not quite sure what to expect but I love the name! Not even sure it’s an heirloom or a paste, but I put it here because it may be an heirloom of another type, if not an heirloom tomato.
When to Plant Tomato Seed
Planting tomato seed time frames will vary depending on your gardening zone. Most seed packets will tell you to plant tomato seed 6-8 weeks before the last frost. Here where I live in gardening zone 8b, the last frost, is April 15th.
But it is usually still too cold for the plants to go outside until around May 15th. This can factor in to when you plant your seed, especially if you do not have a lot of space indoors for your plant starts, or somewhere warm, like a greenhouse, for them to wait out those cold nights.
Folks around here will start as early as February. I tend to wait until the middle of March because I grow so many. About a third to half of my starts get sold and I cannot afford to up pot them into a pot larger than 4″.
If I start much earlier than the middle of March, the plants get too long and leggy for people to safely transport home in that little 4″ pot as most don’t want to take them home until around May 1st. So consider your frost date, and also consider when your night time temperatures get consistently above 50 degrees. These two dates can help you figure out the best time to start your seeds.
Planting Tomato Seed
I use potting soil that I buy at Costco, the organic Miracle Grow Moisture Control Potting Soil and it comes in a 55 quart bag for $9.99. I put the soil in a 14 quart Rubbermaid Bin and add a bit of water to it, and stir it around well. You want the soil damp, but not drippy or soupy.
Fill all the cells with soil and tamp it down good in each cell with your fingers. I indent the soil about a 1/4″ with the fat end of a chopstick, or the eraser end of a pencil, lay down the seed inside the indent, than cover lightly with soil and press down again.
It is very important that the seed be in contact with the soil completely around. I place 2 seeds in each cell if the seed is fresh and I feel confident in it. If it is older seed, or from a swap and I don’t know how old it is, I tend to use 3-4 seeds in each cell.
Than I use a spray bottle and lightly spray the seed until I know that the seed and all surrounding soil is completely damp. If the seed floats up, just poke it back down under the soil. Than place a plastic dome lid on top of the tray (or you can use plastic wrap), place tray on heating mat and your seed is planted.
Germination of Tomato Seed
The next few days, you want to watch the tray. Make sure the soil doesn’t dry out. If it does, take off the lid and spray again with water and then put the lid back on. Once the majority of the seed in the tray has germinated, take of the lid and keep it off. It is only used to keep humidity in while germination takes place.
Caring for the Tomato Starts
After germination and removing the plastic dome lid, place the tray under grow lights and keep it on a heat mat. You want the lights to be very close to the leaves, only about an 1″ above them.
As the plant grows, you will need to move the light up, so it is best if you can hang the light from a chain using “S” hooks, because they grow quickly, and you will be moving the light up often. If the light is too high, or you don’t use a light and place your seedlings on a window sill, the plants will get long and leggy, which does not make for a healthy plant.
It is also a good idea to keep an oscillating fan on the starts, to prevent fungus from growing in soil that is too damp, and it helps make stronger stems. If you don’t have an oscillating fan, move the fan frequently so that it blows from a different angle.
At this point, it is also best to water from the bottom. Use a watering can that has a long spout, lift one seed pack up a little bit, and fill the tray about 1/2 way with water.
I also like to add fish fertilizer to the water. I dilute it about half what the directions say. It is stinky though! So if you are smelling something foul in the house, it may be your seed starts! Just a warning!
Thinning the Tomato Starts
When the second set of leaves starts to grow, is when I take out some tiny scissors, and thin out the starts. I select the strongest looking start in each cell to keep, and then nip any others in that cell down at the soil level.
The strongest seedling is NOT always the tallest. You want a thick healthy looking stem more than anything. You can elect to try to salvage the extra’s, and repot them all, but I find that that are so fragile at this age, I am not willing to take the risk of losing them at this point.
Tomatoes are so easily rooted, I prefer to wait until I begin pruning out the suckers, and root those in water, if I need more of a certain variety.
Up Potting the Tomato Starts
Very quickly your starts will need to be up potted to a minimum of a 4″ pot, or I also like to use Solo Cups that I have cut a couple drainage holes into. I prefer the Solo cups because they are a little deeper.
When transplanting, pick off the bottom leaves of the tomato plant and bury it as deep as you can in the pot. It will send off new roots along the stem that is buried, making for a stronger plant.
If you have the space, you can up pot to a larger pot, but if you have a lot like I do, I just don’t have the space to move them all into larger pots until it is closer to the time they will move outside.
They will still need to be babied at this point. Keep them in a warm space, and ideally, still under grow lights.
But often times they are too tall to go under your seed starting set up. So you might need to revamp the light set up at this point. Or move them out into the greenhouse if you have one. Do not put them outside until temperatures are above 50 degrees.
Steps to Hardening Off Your Tomato Starts
As with all starts, it is very important to harden them off slowly before moving them outdoors full time. Hardening off means, slowly acclimating them to the conditions outdoors. If you just move them outside one day, they will go into shock, and may not recover.
See my article on How to Harden Off Your Seedlings for more info on this. It is a critical step!
Wait until daytime temps are above 50 degrees. The first few days, keep them in a sheltered location. It should not be too windy. It should not be out where they might receive a down pour if it rains.
Do not put them where they might receive direct sun yet. Only put them out for two hours or so the first day. Increase it slowly by an hour or two each day.
After they have slowly become accustomed to being outdoors over a week or so, you can slowly move them into direct sunlight, in a similar fashion as above.
A couple hours the first day, increasing by an hour or two over the next few days. Unless it is really really hot. If it is, wait until the temp goes down or it is more overcast to begin this process.
If it is still below 50 degrees at night, you will have to bring them in at night.
My Other Articles on Growing Tomatoes:
See my article her about How to Plant Tomato Seedlings.
Before planting your tomato seedlings out, do not forget to Harden Off Your Seedlings!
See how to get Free Tomato Plants from Cuttings
If you need a good tomato support system, see how we do it: DIY Tomato Support System
Learn all about The Benefits of Freezing Your Tomato Harvest
See my article here about How to Save Tomato Seed.
And lastly, see How I Make Money Selling Tomato and Pepper Plants